Crítica del acomodo razonable como instrumento jurídico del multiculturalismo
Cargando...
Fecha
2009-07-22
Autores
Título de la revista
ISSN de la revista
Título del volumen
Editor
Universidad de Valencia = Universitat de València: Instituto de Derechos Humanos
Resumen
En el marco de las actuales sociedades multiculturales se hace necesario explorar vías de profundización democrática que permitan adaptar nuestros parámetros jurídicos tradicionales a la creciente y cambiante diversidad. El acomodo razonable se nos presenta como uno de los instrumentos jurídicos que puede adquirir un importante protagonismo en este proceso de pluralización democrática. Desde la experiencia canadiense y quebequesa del acomodo razonable debe plantearse la posibilidad de importar a Europa este modo de flexibilizar el ejercicio de los derechos fundamentales en atención a la diversidad cultural o identitaria. Esto implica plantear una crítica a su funcionalidad puesto que aún no se ha demostrado la eficacia general de la técnica del acomodo razonable aplicada a los distintos ámbitos de la identidad humana, religiosa o lingüística.
Within the framework of today’s multicultural societies, it is necessary to explore new ways of deepening in Democracy to adapt our traditional legal schemes to the evolving and growing diversity. Reasonable accommodation is one of the legal instruments that can enjoy a particular relevance in this process of democratic pluralization. After analysing the Canadian and Quebecois experiences on reasonable accommodation it must be considered the possibility of importing to Europe this way of adapting the implementation of fundamental rights according to cultural or identity diversity. Nevertheless, there is also a scope for criticism around the way reasonable accommodation is being used in those models, and relevant elements of identity on which it has not yet properly implemented.
Within the framework of today’s multicultural societies, it is necessary to explore new ways of deepening in Democracy to adapt our traditional legal schemes to the evolving and growing diversity. Reasonable accommodation is one of the legal instruments that can enjoy a particular relevance in this process of democratic pluralization. After analysing the Canadian and Quebecois experiences on reasonable accommodation it must be considered the possibility of importing to Europe this way of adapting the implementation of fundamental rights according to cultural or identity diversity. Nevertheless, there is also a scope for criticism around the way reasonable accommodation is being used in those models, and relevant elements of identity on which it has not yet properly implemented.
Palabras clave
Multiculturalismo
Derechos
Diversidad
Canadá
Acomodo razonable
Multiculturalism
Rights
Diversity
Canada
Reasonable accomodation
Derechos
Diversidad
Canadá
Acomodo razonable
Multiculturalism
Rights
Diversity
Canada
Reasonable accomodation
Descripción
Materias
Cita
Ruiz Vieytez, E. J. (2009). Crítica del acomodo razonable como instrumento jurídico del multiculturalismo. Cuadernos electrónicos de filosofía del derecho, 18, 1-22.