Subordiscriminación y discriminación interseccional: elementos para una teoría del derecho antidiscriminatorio
Cargando...
Fecha
2011-12-11
Título de la revista
ISSN de la revista
Título del volumen
Editor
Universidad de Granada
Resumen
Este trabajo se inscribe en una revisión in progress del Derecho antidiscriminatorio moderno que las autoras vienen efectuando desde hace más de tres lustros. En la primera parte del mismo se examinan los textos de una filósofa política y de dos juristas esta-dounidenses (I. M. Young, C. A. MacKinnon y K. Crensahw) que inspiran la propuesta de un concepto de discriminación y de una visión de la interseccionalidad basados en el reconocimiento de los sistemas de opresión. La segunda parte se centra en el análisis del concepto de discriminación múltiple o interseccional propuesto por la doctrina jurídica española a partir de la jurisprudencia referida al caso de una mujer (“La Nena”) casada por el rito gitano que ve denegada su pensión de viudedad. A partir de lo anterior, el trabajo concluye con una serie de propuestas entre las que destacan las referidas a la necesidad de evitar que el discurso sobre la interseccionalidad disuelva la identidad política de los grupos en la individualidad, refuerce el sistema sexo-género y consolide un Derecho anti-discriminatorio de corte excesivamente jurisprudencial.
This work is part of a revision in progress revisiting of modern Antidiscrimination Law that the authors have been carrying out over the last fifteen years. The first part examines texts by a US political philosopher and two legal scholars (I. M. Young, C. A. MacKinnon and K. Crenshaw), that have inspired a proposed concept of discrimination and an understanding of intersectionality based on the acknowledgement of systems of oppression. The second part focuses on the analysis of the concept of multiple or intersectional discrimination proposed by the Spanish legal doctrine starting from the legal case of “La Nena”, a woman married by the Gipsy ritual that was denied her widow’s benefits. From the above, the paper concludes with a series of proposals, among which those related to the need to avoid that the intersectionality discourse disaggregates group political identity into individuality, reinforces the sex-gender system, or strengthens an excessively judgebased Antidiscrimination Law.
This work is part of a revision in progress revisiting of modern Antidiscrimination Law that the authors have been carrying out over the last fifteen years. The first part examines texts by a US political philosopher and two legal scholars (I. M. Young, C. A. MacKinnon and K. Crenshaw), that have inspired a proposed concept of discrimination and an understanding of intersectionality based on the acknowledgement of systems of oppression. The second part focuses on the analysis of the concept of multiple or intersectional discrimination proposed by the Spanish legal doctrine starting from the legal case of “La Nena”, a woman married by the Gipsy ritual that was denied her widow’s benefits. From the above, the paper concludes with a series of proposals, among which those related to the need to avoid that the intersectionality discourse disaggregates group political identity into individuality, reinforces the sex-gender system, or strengthens an excessively judgebased Antidiscrimination Law.
Palabras clave
Derecho antidiscriminatorio
Feminismo
Subordiscriminación
Sistemas de opresión
Discriminación interseccional
Antidiscrimination Law
Feminism
Subordiscrimination
Systems of oppression
Intersectional discrimination
Feminismo
Subordiscriminación
Sistemas de opresión
Discriminación interseccional
Antidiscrimination Law
Feminism
Subordiscrimination
Systems of oppression
Intersectional discrimination
Descripción
Materias
Cita
Barrère Unzueta, M. Á., & Morondo Taramundi, D. (2011). Subordiscriminación y discriminación interseccional: elementos para una teoría del derecho antidiscriminatorio. Anales de la Cátedra Francisco Suárez, 45, 15-42. https://doi.org/10.30827/ACFS.V45I0.523